Shop by
Replacing a furnace or central air conditioner is a major home expense. The harder decision is whether to replace just the failing unit or upgrade both at the same time. This guide explains typical cost ranges and the situations where a full, matched replacement usually makes more sense.
Use the table below to compare whether replacing one unit is usually enough versus when upgrading both is often the better choice.
| Situation |
Replacing one system can make sense when |
Replacing both often makes more sense when |
|---|---|---|
| Age | The other unit is newer and has a solid service history. | Both units are older, or one is old enough that another major repair is likely soon. |
| Compatibility | A technician confirms the remaining equipment is compatible and can be properly matched. | Your system would be mismatched, which can reduce efficiency and create warranty or performance issues. |
| Budget | You need the lowest immediate cost, and the other unit is truly in good shape. | You can budget for a larger project now and want to reduce repeat labor costs later. |
| Comfort and efficiency | Comfort is acceptable, and you only need a functional repair. | Comfort problems suggest duct issues, sizing problems, or an aging system that is not performing well overall. |
Prices vary widely by home size, efficiency level, local labor rates, and installation complexity. Use ranges as planning numbers, not as a quote.
Most “replacement” pricing assumes you already have ductwork and basic electrical service in place. The biggest add-ons that raise totals are duct repairs, major electrical upgrades, permits, code updates, difficult access, and high-efficiency equipment choices.
Get at least two itemized quotes that separate equipment, labor, and add-ons. That is the fastest way to understand why one bid is higher than another.
1. The systems are connected, especially in a forced-air home
In many homes, the AC system uses the furnace blower and ductwork to move cool air. That means heating and cooling performance depends on shared parts like airflow, duct condition, and the indoor coil area above the furnace.
When you replace both, the installer can size and set up the full system as one package instead of mixing new and old components.
2. “Matched” systems help avoid efficiency and performance problems
Cooling systems are tested and rated as a combination of indoor and outdoor components. Mismatched equipment can reduce efficiency and create performance issues.
If your quote includes a new outdoor unit, ask whether the indoor coil and blower setup will be properly matched for the rated efficiency.
3. One big job can reduce duplicated labor
When you replace one unit now and the second unit later, you often pay for repeated trips, repeated setup work, and repeated commissioning. Many cost guides note that combined replacement commonly reduces total cost compared with doing each job separately.
If both units are aging, bundling the work often reduces total disruption and avoids paying for the same labor categories twice.
4. Refrigerant transitions and efficiency standards can affect “partial” replacements
The industry has been transitioning to lower-GWP refrigerants under EPA rules starting in 2025, and equipment compatibility matters when components do not match.
If you are replacing the AC side, ask your contractor how refrigerant choice and system matching affects your options.
Replacing only the furnace can make sense when the AC system is newer, runs well, and does not show signs of coil issues, refrigerant leaks, or chronic performance problems.
Common situations where furnace-only replacement is reasonable:
Furnace-only replacement is usually a reasonable plan when the cooling equipment has enough useful life left to justify keeping it.
Replacing only the AC can make sense when the furnace is newer, reliable, and the blower setup can support the new cooling equipment correctly.
Common situations where AC-only replacement is reasonable:
AC-only replacement is most successful when the installer verifies system compatibility instead of simply swapping the outdoor unit.
Replacing both is often the cleanest plan when any of these are true:
If you are already facing a large repair and the other unit is aging, replacing both often reduces risk of another large expense soon.
You cannot eliminate the cost of equipment, but you can reduce avoidable add ons and repeat visits.
Whether you replace one unit or both, the system still depends on steady airflow through the return side. That is where the HVAC filter does its job.
If your home uses a ducted furnace and central AC, both usually pull return air through the same filter location. That is why correct filter size and a consistent replacement schedule matter after any upgrade.
Filterbuy sells the best replacement HVAC filters that are US-made in common MERV options, including MERV 8, MERV 11, and MERV 13. We also offer free shipping within the U.S. and Auto Delivery for scheduled replacements.
A filter will not prevent every repair, but it helps protect the blower and coil from dust buildup, which supports consistent airflow. After any replacement, protecting airflow is one of the most important maintenance steps.
In most ducted systems, yes. The furnace blower typically moves air for both heating and cooling, so the filter is usually in the shared return path.
Replace both when one unit is failing and the other is near the end of its lifespan, when efficiency is a priority, or when the system is mismatched and not performing well together.
Yes. Many homes replace only the failing unit. A technician should confirm the new unit will work correctly with the existing equipment and that the system stays properly sized and compatible.
It is more likely when the equipment is old, repairs are frequent, refrigerant type changes affect the AC side, or the contractor finds compatibility issues that would limit performance with a mixed system.
Often, yes. There can be some labor overlap, and it may reduce repeat service visits. The total cost is still higher than replacing one unit because you are replacing more equipment.
Not directly. A filter helps protect the blower and coil from dust buildup, which supports airflow and can reduce wear over time. You still need correct sizing, installation, and regular maintenance.
You should confirm the correct filter size and thickness for the new setup. If airflow is a concern, ask the installer what filter level the system can handle without restricting airflow.
